Date | 2026-11-16 14:31:55
— Same electrical ratings, a five-fold gap in tensile strength.
Inside low-voltage electrical equipment, BMC and SMC are often compared as if they were two grades of the same thing. They are not. One arrives as a bulk charge, the other as a sheet, and what they can be moulded into differs. Picking the wrong one can mean cutting a new mould.
The electrical numbers do not separate them: both sit at tracking index ≥600 V and electric strength ≥20 kV/mm. Tensile strength does — SMC-1 reaches ≥100 MPa, BMC 1615 reaches ≥20 MPa. So the question is not which material is better. It is which grade your part needs.
Work through three checks in this order. Each one removes options.
Temperature. Above 130 °C, BMC 1616 and BMC 1615 drop out. What remains is all SMC grades, plus BMC 1625 and BMC 1620.
Load. Parts that carry assembly stress, absorb impact or span a large area go to SMC. Parts that mainly insulate, locate or separate are served well by BMC.
Shape. Cavities with many inserts, dense ribs or local thin walls favour BMC. Large parts with gentle curvature favour SMC.
Three checks usually settle it:
| Part characteristic | SMC | BMC |
|---|---|---|
| Service temperature above 130 °C | All grades (≥155 °C) | 1625 and 1620 only |
| Carries assembly stress or impact | Suited | Light-load parts only |
| Large area, gentle curvature | Suited | Short fibre, limited load capacity |
| Many inserts, dense ribs, local thin walls | Weak flow, short shots likely | Suited |
| Insulation and location, little load | Over-specified, higher cost | Adequate |
The sections below explain why each check sits where it does.
A common assumption says: if the requirement is high, use SMC. It does not hold. Both materials carry the same requirement values — tracking index, electric strength, arc resistance, insulation resistance — with no distinction between the two families.
The reason is simple. Both are unsaturated polyester systems reinforced with glass fibre. Electrical performance comes from the formulation, not from whether the fibre arrives as a sheet or as a bulk charge. "Which one insulates better" is therefore not a question worth asking. It is a threshold both clear.
| Property | Requirement | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Tracking index (PTI) | ≥600 V | Surface resistance to tracking under electric field and contamination |
| Electric strength | ≥20 kV/mm | Power-frequency short-time breakdown |
| Arc resistance | ≥180 s | High-voltage, low-current arc discharge |
| Insulation resistance, normal | ≥1.0×10¹³ Ω | — |
| Insulation resistance, 24 h wet | ≥1.0×10¹² Ω | One order of magnitude retained after moisture uptake |
| Glow-wire flammability | 960 / 850 / 650 °C | Grade dependent; 960 °C is the top band |
Note: these figures are the minimums set in Wenzhou Jintong's internal standard Q/JTJ0001-2025 — the same document our outgoing inspection runs against. They are commitments rather than marketing numbers, and they apply to every grade in both families.
Tensile and impact strength are where the two families separate. SMC carries longer fibre with better orientation: SMC-1 reaches ≥100 MPa in tension, five times BMC 1615 at ≥20 MPa. Impact strength is ≥90 kJ/m² against ≥25 kJ/m², a factor of 3.6. This is not a marginal difference — it is a different class of part.
SMC grades:
| Property | SMC-1 | SMC-2 | SMC-3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tensile strength (MPa) | ≥100 | ≥60 | ≥55 |
| Charpy impact, unnotched (kJ/m²) | ≥90 | ≥60 | ≥45 |
| Flexural strength (MPa) | ≥170 | ≥160 | ≥140 |
| Temperature index (°C) | ≥155 | ≥155 | ≥155 |
BMC grades:
| Property | BMC 1625 | BMC 1620 | BMC 1616 | BMC 1615 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tensile strength (MPa) | ≥35 | ≥30 | ≥25 | ≥20 |
| Charpy impact, unnotched (kJ/m²) | ≥40 | ≥35 | ≥30 | ≥25 |
| Flexural strength (MPa) | ≥140 | ≥130 | ≥110 | ≥90 |
| Temperature index (°C) | ≥155 | ≥155 | ≥130 | ≥130 |
Note: values from the same internal standard. The tables are split so the trend inside each family stays readable — from SMC-1 to SMC-3, and from BMC 1625 to 1615, each is a single downward curve.
Read them in two steps. First, does the part carry load? Load-bearing parts, large panels and impact-resistant structures want the headroom SMC provides; parts that insulate, locate or separate are fine on BMC. Second, check temperature as a separate gate: all SMC grades and BMC 1625/1620 sit at ≥155 °C, while BMC 1616/1615 sit at ≥130 °C.
SMC is not the universal answer simply because it is stronger. It arrives as a sheet — good drape, weaker flow. That suits large parts with gentle curvature. BMC flows, so it fills cavities with dense ribs, metal inserts or local thin walls. The more complex the shape, the stronger the case for BMC. This check is not about performance; it is about whether the part can be made at all.
| Process step | Parameter |
|---|---|
| Mould temperature | 135–170 °C. Lower end for walls ≤3 mm, upper end for walls >5 mm; uniformity within ±5 °C |
| Low-pressure closing | 0.5–3.0 MPa at 10–20 mm/s |
| High-pressure dwell | 3.5–14.0 MPa, set by flow length and projected area |
| Cure time | 1.2–1.5 min per mm of maximum wall thickness |
| Charge weight | Theoretical volume × flash allowance 1.05–1.15 |
| Material storage | Sealed at 25 ± 5 °C, ≤60 % RH; shelf life applies after opening |
Note: process window from Wenzhou Jintong's process specification Q/JTJ0002-2025, taken from production rather than calculated.
This check also carries the highest cost of being wrong. A cavity is designed around one material's flow behaviour; switching later usually means recalculating gate, venting and pressure gradient, which can amount to a significant mould change.
No universal price per kilogram settles this. Four variables drive part cost: grade (higher mechanical grades cost more to formulate), part weight and projected area (which set the press tonnage), mould complexity (inserts, slides, cavitation), and batch size together with post-processing.
The practical order is: settle the grade from temperature and load, confirm the shape can be moulded, then work out part cost from annual volume. Comparing unit price first tends to land on a grade that does not fit, and rework costs more than the saving.
Paper data narrows the range; it does not confirm it. Before locking a grade, run a small trial batch on the actual mould and measure dimensions, appearance and assembly fit. Wenzhou Jintong has worked in thermoset composites since 2001, with material, tooling and moulding in house, so a trial runs on the same chain that will produce the part.
Usually not. A cavity is designed around one material's flow behaviour, and the two differ. Sharing a mould means designing for both windows before cutting steel, then proving it by trial.
Yes, decided part by part. Structural parts in SMC and insulating separators in BMC is a common combination. Both are unsaturated polyester systems, so thermal expansion and moisture behaviour are close, and one tolerance scheme can usually cover both. Final confirmation still comes from measuring the parts.
It depends on the part, not the batch size. At low volume the mould dominates cost, so the question becomes whether the mould can be got right first time. Complex parts with inserts stabilise faster in BMC; simple large parts need a simpler mould in SMC. Batch size changes amortisation, not material fit.
Size the mechanics first, then solve the moulding. If SMC's headroom is genuinely required, consider local reinforcement in the mould, repositioning inserts, or a higher-flow SMC grade. If the load is modest, BMC is the simpler route. This is the case most worth proving with a trial run.
For technical data sheets, grade recommendations, or a discussion about your specific requirements:
📧 wendy.qiu@smcbmc.com 📞 +86-13868305300